• Rev. Conrad M. Schottfer, D.D. 1890-1892
• Rev. Joseph (Giuseppe) Ali 1892-1894
• Msgr. Ernesto D'Aquila 1894-1933 Pastor from till May 8, 1933
• Rev. Gaetano Ruggiero May 15th, 1933 till October 21, 1933
• Rev. Leonard Viccaro 1933-1943
• Rev. Richard Calligaro (Administrator) December 4, 1943-June 29th,1968
• Rev. Francis N. Di Giorgio (Adminstrator from June 29th, 1968, Appointed Pastor June 24th 1972 - October 29th, 1979)1968-1979
• Rev. Donald Di Pasquale December 15th, 1979-1981
• Rev. Msgr. Peter Zaccardo January 17th 1981-November 12th, 1988
• Rev. Robert G. Marotta December 23rd 1988-1996
• Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio 1996-1999 (Bishop of Brooklyn 1999-Present)
• Msgr. Joseph F. Ambrosio 1999-2020 (Admistrator from July 1, 1996- November 30, 1999; Pastor from November 30, 1999-October 4, 2020)
• Rev. Danny S. Rodrigues January 1, 2021-Present

Rev. Adauto Alves 2018-2019
Rev. Anthony Forte 2008-2013
Rev. Eugene Bernas
Rev. Dennis Kaelin
Rev. Joseph Kokeram
Rev. Pasquale Papalia
Rev. Richard Kelly
Rev. Thomas Blind
Rev. Msgr. Thomas Guarino 1979
Rev. Raphael Pezzelli, T.O.R.

Rev. Anthony Granato 
Rev. Francis Andreoni
Rev. Joseph F.X. Cevetello 1964
Rev. Gerard Graziano 1964
Rev. John De Sanctis 1958


Deacons:

Rev.Charles M. Kelly- 2005
Rev.Msgr. Michael Andreano 1999-2000
Rev. Walter Lucey 1997-1998